I definitely have to go with Star Wars. I did like LOTR alot but Star Wars by a long shot. Have always been watching Star Wars my entire life and everything that goes into it makes it so phenominal. The ideas that went into making Star Wars, from start to finish, makes it more of a fascinating and more exciting story than LOTR. All they do in LOTR, is take a ring, go on a 5 day hike up the mountain, where they have to avoid insects, trees, and ghosts, and then drop the ring in lava. But now if you look at Star Wars, you definitely have a lot more going on. You have tons more action and a better storyline. Also they don't have to worry about destroying some ring.