3,101

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

The Conjuring

Premonition 2004 VS Infection (2004 film)

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Infection

Rare Exports vs Black Christmas

3,103

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Black Christmas

Black Christmas (remake) vs. Silent Night (remake)

3,104

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Silent Night

Hatchet 2 vs. Hatchet 3

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Hatchet 2

Dolly Dearest vs. Childs Play 3

3,106

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Child's Play 3

Trollhunter vs. Cloverfield

3,107

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Trollhunter

Terror Train vs. Prom Night

3,108

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Terror Train

The Conjuring vs. Insidious 2

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Insidious 2 (but it's a close one)

Tremors vs The Host

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Tremors

Phantasm 2 vs. Return of the Living Dead 3

3,111

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Phantasm 2

The Human Centipede vs. A Serbian Film

3,112

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

A Serbian Film

Alucarda vs. Vampyres

3,113

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Not seen them yet!

Drag me to hell VS Lucky (2004)

3,114

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Drag Me to Hell

Terror Train vs. Midnight Meat Train

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Midnight meat train
Curse of the fly vs return of the fly

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Return of the fly

Bloody murder 2 vs Satan's little helper

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Satan's Little Helper

You're Next vs. The Strangers

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

You're Next

Poltergeist vs. The Haunting (either version)

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Poltergeist

Ash from evil dead vs Seth gecko from from dusk til dawn

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Ash

VHS vs. Trick R Treat (2009)

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Trick R Treat

Scream vs. I Know What You Did Last Summer

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Scream

Scream vs. A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984)

3,123

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

I feel dirty that I even have to answer this versus. Nightmare by a country mile.
Sticking with the same theme of a turd against a cherry:

Rob Zombie's Halloween 2 vs. Jaws

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Jaws

Aliens vs. Alien

Re: The X vs X Horror Game

Aliens

Cry wolf vs laid to rest