I was more of a tales from the cypt and x file guy. I recently was told from someone (Have not seen yet).
American Gothic (1995 Gary Cole/ Lucas Black/ Paige Turco/ Brenda Bakke).
Was great but only lasted one season. Most likely due to the quality of TV shows going on at that time and not enough exposure (I never heard about it untill now).
It was created by Shaun Cassidy , it suffered the same fate as another Cassidy show which is the reason he watched it called Invasion. Sam Raimi was the executive producer.
He mentioned how it is pretty creepy (very rare quaity in a TV show, to say the least) and very well written.
Cole, as Sheriff Lucas Buck, gave a memorable performance as the bad guy. The entire series is available to watch for free at Flixster and net flix.