I didn't really get scared by shows as a kid too much either, though watched all the horror type shows I could. One of my favorites was Wolf (I think it was called), one of the first shows Fox had as a new network.
I loved it when non-horror shows would have a dark show. Like when The Greatest American Hero had the haunted house and the spirit. ScyFy had a marathon and I got to see that one recently. Also...and no one seems to remember this...remember when there was that episode (might of been a two parter) of the Incredible Hulk where there was a bad Hulk? The two fought.
I also loved Halloween episodes of shows. Roseanne (yes I brought up Roseanne on a horror thread!) had some great ones...not scary but fun. Ok...now I'm just reminiscing.