Okay, folks, voting time is over. The results of HM's Deadliest Horror Movie Warrior, Round 1:
Shaun, 8 total votes:
7 explained votes x 5 points = 35
1 unexplained vote x 1 point = 1
Total: 36 Votes
Tar Man, 5 total votes
5 explained votes x 5 points = 25
Total: 25 votes
Winner: SHAUN
Thanks to all those who participated in this round, and look for Round 2, which will be up shortly. 
EDIT: Heh. Okay, I actually HAVE to vote if I want to see poll results LOL So FYI, in future I'll always vote for the 1st option, so everyone can fairly know which opponent's total to deduct mine from.
Yeesh...